Dining Guide
Where to Eat & Drink on Nantucket: A Complete Dining Guide
Nantucket punches well above its weight when it comes to food and drink. For an island of roughly 15,000 year-round residents, the dining scene is genuinely exceptional — fresh seafood, creative kitchens, beloved local institutions, and a handful of spots that would hold their own in any major city.
This guide covers the full range: fine dining and casual spots, sandwich shops and seafood markets, bakeries, grocery stores, and places to stock up on wine and spirits. Everything is alphabetized within each category, with price estimates to help you plan.
Price guide: $ = under $15/person · $$ = $15–$35 · $$$ = $35–$65 · $$$$ = $65+
Restaurants & Casual Dining
45 Surfside Bakery & Café $$ Breakfast and lunch daily, with burritos, breakfast sandwiches, salads, subs, wraps, smoothies, and fresh-baked goods. A convenient neighborhood spot just down the road. 45 Surfside Road · 774-333-3981 · 45surfsidebakery.com
Brant Point Grill $$$ Classic waterfront dining at the White Elephant with sweeping harbor views. Open for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and Sunday brunch. Fresh seafood, grilled steaks, and New England favorites in an elegant but approachable setting. 50 Easton Street · 800-445-6574 · Reservations via OpenTable
Breeze Restaurant $$$ Contemporary New England cuisine at The Nantucket Hotel, with indoor dining, a lively bar, and a wraparound porch. Open for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and Sunday brunch. 77 Easton Street · 508-228-4730 · Reservations via OpenTable
Brotherhood of Thieves $$ A Nantucket institution with 50+ years of history. The downstairs pub serves comfort classics in an 1840s whaling-bar atmosphere; upstairs is a livelier surf-inspired restaurant with an outdoor patio and the Notch Whiskey Bar. Burgers, seafood, sushi, and craft cocktails. 23 Broad Street · 774-325-5812 · brotherhoodofthieves.com
The Chanticleer $$$$ One of Nantucket's most romantic dining experiences, set in a rose-covered cottage in 'Sconset. Seasonal, locally inspired cuisine in intimate dining rooms or on the iconic garden patio. A destination for special occasions. 9 New Street, Siasconset · thechanticleernantucket.com · Reservations via Resy
Cisco Brewers $ Nantucket's most iconic outdoor gathering spot — a brewery, winery, and distillery in one lively setting. Live music, rotating food trucks, and a high-energy crowd. More of an experience than a restaurant, but a must-visit. 5 Bartlett Farm Road · 508-325-5929 · ciscobrewers.com
Crosswinds $ Casual, all-day dining inside Nantucket Memorial Airport. Breakfast, lunch, and dinner with generous portions and daily specials. A reliable, no-fuss option year-round. 14 Airport Road · 508-228-6005
Cru $$$ The place for oysters and a sunset cocktail, right on the harbor. The raw bar is exceptional, and the setting is hard to beat on a warm evening. 1 Straight Wharf · 508-228-9278 · crunantucket.com · Reservations via Resy
Dune $$$ A downtown favorite known for creative, seasonal American cuisine in a warm, intimate setting. One of the island's most consistently praised kitchens. 20 Broad Street · 508-228-5550 · dunenantucket.com · Reservations via OpenTable
Fairgrounds $$ Reinvigorated for the 2026 season with grab-and-go breakfast, hearty dine-in fare, live entertainment, outdoor patio, yard games, a kids menu, and easy parking. Good vibes and a relaxed atmosphere. 27 Fairgrounds Road · 508-228-4095 · fairgroundsnantucket.com
The Juice Bar $ Nantucket's beloved homemade ice cream shop, a summer institution. Long lines are part of the experience — worth every minute. 12 Broad Street · 508-228-5799 · thejuicebarnantucket.com
Lola 41 $$$ A lively, crowd-pleasing spot with a menu spanning sushi, tacos, and wood-fired dishes. Great for groups with varied tastes. Reserve ahead in summer. 15 South Beach Street · 508-325-4001 · lola41.com · Reservations via OpenTable
Millie's $$ Excellent fish tacos and sandwiches with a laid-back beach vibe, out at Madaket. A perfect stop after watching the sunset. 326 Madaket Road · 508-325-5700 · milliesnantucket.com
Nobadeer Cafe $ A casual, family-friendly spot for morning pick-me-ups, casual lunches, and sweet treats. From 3–10 pm, the Nobabar opens for craft cocktails and evening bites. 1 Miller Lane · 508-228-6900 · nobadeercafe.com
The Proprietors $$$ A local institution and one of the island's most celebrated restaurants. Creative cocktails, a thoughtful wine list, and a seasonally driven menu. Reserve well ahead in summer. 9 India Street · 508-228-7477 · proprietorsnantucket.com · Reservations via Resy
Queequeg's $$ A cozy New American bistro tucked just off Main Street. Eclectic seasonal menu, charming outdoor patio, warm atmosphere, and a thoughtful wine list. A quieter, more intimate dinner option in town. 6 Oak Street · 508-325-0992 · queequegsnantucket.com
Rose & Crown $$ One of Nantucket's longest-running pubs, in the heart of downtown. Casual burgers and beer by day; DJs, karaoke, and dancing by night. A reliable late-night destination. 23 South Water Street · 508-228-2595 · roseandcrownnantucket.com
Ships Inn $$$ A refined American brasserie inside a historic 1831 whaling captain's home. Candlelit dining rooms, thoughtfully prepared seasonal dishes, an extensive wine list, and signature soufflés. 13 Fair Street · 508-228-0400 · shipsinnnantucket.com · Reservations via OpenTable
The Summer House $$$$ Two distinct oceanfront experiences in 'Sconset: the main restaurant offers romantic, candlelit dining with live piano and elevated coastal cuisine; the Beachside Bistro is relaxed open-air dining steps from the sand. 17 Ocean Avenue, Siasconset · 508-227-9976 · thesummerhouse.com · Reservations via OpenTable
Sushi Sean's 11:11 Market & Bistro $$ Fresh, creative Japanese cuisine in a relaxed modern setting. Made-to-order sushi, ramen, and bold specialty rolls. Dine in, takeout, or catering. 130 Pleasant Street · 774-485-2078
TOPPER'S $$$$ Nantucket's most refined dining experience, set between the bay and the ocean at The Wauwinet. Seasonal tasting menus, impeccable service, and an award-winning wine list. A true destination dinner. 120 Wauwinet Road · 508-228-0145 · wauwinet.com · Reservations via OpenTable
Town $$$ A vibrant, high-energy spot downtown known for sushi, bold fusion dishes, and craft cocktails. The lively dining room flows into the iconic outdoor Tree Bar — as much nightlife as restaurant. 4 East Chestnut Street · 508-325-8696 · townnantucket.com
Ventuno $$$$ The spot for a special occasion dinner. Refined Italian cuisine in an elegant setting just off Main Street. One of the island's most polished kitchens. 21 Federal Street · 508-228-4242 · ventunonantucket.com · Reservations via OpenTable
Seafood Markets & Casual Takeout
Sayle's Seafood $$ A classic Nantucket fish market and takeout spot. Fried clams, scallops, lobster dinners, and housemade clam chowder — prepared simply and served ready to go. Pick up your order and head to the harbor or the beach. 99 Washington Street Extension · 508-228-4599 · saylesseafood.com
Bakeries, Cafés & Sweet Shops
Aunt Leah's Fudge $ A beloved Nantucket sweet shop on Straight Wharf known for rich, handmade fudge and signature chocolate-covered cranberries. A classic stop for gifts or a treat. 16 Straight Wharf · 508-228-1017 · auntleahsfudge.com
Nantucket Bake Shop $ A longtime island bakery making fresh Portuguese bread, donuts, cookies, cakes, and pastries daily in small batches. Arrive early for the best selection. 17½ Old South Road · 508-228-2797
Grocery Stores & Markets
Bartlett's Ocean View Farm $ Nantucket's largest and oldest working farm, offering fresh local produce, a prepared food kitchen, bakery, grocery market, garden center, and a curated wine and beer selection. A staple stop for beach picnic provisions, quick meals, and everyday island needs. Weekly wine tastings in season. 33 Bartlett Farm Road · 508-228-9403 · bartlettsfarm.com
Stop & Shop $ The island's full-service grocery store for everyday staples, household goods, and a wide range of groceries. The most practical option for stocking the house for the week. 31 Sparks Avenue · 508-228-0028 · stopandshop.com
Wine, Beer & Spirits
Cisco Brewers $ See listing above under Restaurants. Also a great place to pick up canned beer, bottled wine, and spirits to take home. 5 Bartlett Farm Road · 508-325-5929 · ciscobrewers.com
The Islander $$ A family-owned wine and spirits shop with one of the largest selections on the island. Fine wines, single malt scotches, craft beer, and hand-rolled cigars. Knowledgeable staff and a focus on quality. 15 Old South Road · 508-228-5855
Mór Wine $$ A boutique bottle shop in the heart of downtown with a carefully curated collection of wine and spirits. From everyday bottles to hard-to-find vermouths, aperitifs, and digestifs. Every price point represented. 16 Federal Street · morwinenantucket.com
Nantucket Wine & Spirits $$ A full-service, family-owned shop open year-round with an extensive selection of wine, craft beer, and spirits from around the world. Located near Stop & Shop — convenient for a one-stop run. Delivery available. 31 Sparks Avenue · 508-228-1136 · nantucketwinespirits.com
A Note on Reservations
Nantucket's best restaurants fill up weeks in advance during peak season (July and August). If you have a specific dinner in mind — The Proprietors, TOPPER'S, Ventuno, The Chanticleer — book before you arrive. Most restaurants use OpenTable or Resy; links are included above where available.
For casual spots, walk-ins are generally fine, though popular lunch counters and seafood markets can have lines during peak hours. Arriving early or late in the lunch window usually helps.
If you'd like a personal recommendation based on your group size, preferences, or a special occasion, don't hesitate to reach out to the property manager — happy to help point you in the right direction.